Since we had just dined at Liberty Tree on our last trip, I normally would not have returned here so soon (even though we had enjoyed our lunch). However, our friends that we were meeting up with for dinner at Magic Kingdom had chosen to eat here before they invited us to join them. And given that there were 9 of us, that limited our dining choices. Thankfully, Liberty Tree Tavern was able to accommodate our large group and since it is a pre-set AYCTE meal that is served family-style at your table, it made things much easier than having 9 people order different things off the menu.
So let’s start this review by showing you the menu…

They started by taking our (included with our meal) drink orders, followed by bringing out bowls of salad and baskets of rolls. This all happened within about 5 minutes of being seated.

Declaration Salad – Mixed Greens, Apples, Cranberries, and Shredded Cheese with House-made Honey Shallot Vinaigrette Dressing
I love this salad! I remember getting it frequently when Liberty Tree Tavern had an a la carte menu. It was delicious as usual and I gave it a perfect rating of 5. Don enjoyed it but wasn’t quite as enthusiastic about it as me. He said it was a very good salad though and gave it a rating of 4 1/2. Andrew didn’t have any because he wanted to save the room for the better things to come, lol.
He did however partake of the rolls…

These were good Parker House-style rolls covered with herb and garlic butter. No complaints. Andrew and I both rated them a 4, but Don gave them a rating of 4 1/2.
Next came the Patriot’s Platters. Here is a platter with the three meats..

This platter held slices of Roasted Turkey and (per the menu) Smoked Pork Loin, but it seemed more like Ham. Also hidden in the back of the platter was the Pot Roast. Only Don tried the Pork Loin and he said it was good and gave it a rating of 4. A rating of 4 was unanimously given to the Turkey by the three of us. But the star of the meats was definitely the Pot Roast. YUM! The beef was shredded and there were carrots and celery added along with gravy, making it almost like a beef stew. The guys gave it a rating of 4 1/2 and I gave it a 5, the second perfect score given at this meal.
There were only two items which we asked for more of and the Pot Roast was one of these…

As you can, the other thing we requested more of were the Mashed Potatoes. These were first brought to our table on a platter with Herbed Stuffing, Green Beans, and Cranberry Sauce…

The potatoes were mashed with the skin on and Don and I really enjoyed them. Both of us gave them a rating of 4 1/2. Andrew wasn’t quite as impressed with them. He thought they were pretty good, but just slightly above average and gave them a rating of 3 1/2. I felt the same way about the stuffing. It was good but tasted pretty much like Stove Top dressing. Since I do like Stove Top I gave the stuffing a rating of 3 1/2. The guys didn’t even try it. As for the green beans, I again gave them a rating of 3 1/2. Don thought they tasted a little too “garlicky” and gave them only a 3. Andrew also passed on the green beans.
So for the sides, that just leaves the Macaroni & Cheese, which was served in a separate bowl…

Just like last year, the Macaroni & Cheese was a disappointment. It was very bland. Andrew and I both gave it a rating of 2, the lowest rating of this meal. Don remembered that it wasn’t good last year and didn’t even bother trying it this time.
One person of our group is Vegetarian so she was brought this Vegan Meatloaf…

She thought this was better than average.
And now for the dessert, which is normally one of my favorites at Liberty Tree Tavern…

Because one of our group was celebrating her birthday they added sprinkles (and less toffee pieces than usual) to our Ooey Gooey Toffee Cake (Vanilla Toffee Cake topped with Vanilla Ice Cream and Chocolate Sauce). Normally I would rate this at least a 4 1/2 but I didn’t like the sprinkles so I deducted a 1/2 point and gave the Birthday version of the Ooey Gooey Toffee Cake a rating of 4. To my surprise, Don and Andrew thought this was just okay and gave it only a rating of 3. Maybe they were just too full at this point to fully enjoy it???
Oh but speaking of sprinkles, our group included a 4 year old who wanted only the ice cream for dessert. Our server asked if he wanted sprinkles and of course he replied yes.

YIKES!! Be careful what you ask for here, especially when it comes to sprinkles. Haha!
But other than the “over-sprinkling” of our desserts, we had very good service here. Our server did well with splitting our checks. I paid our check with my Disney Chase VISA card and received a 10% discount. The remaining 6 of our group were on the Disney Dining Plan so their check was also a bit more complicated. But our server took this all in stride.
I highly recommend Liberty Tree Tavern when dining at Magic Kingdom with a large group. The pre-set menu and family-style service is very efficient and therefore ideal. It’s a fast way to get a group of hungry people fed and still allows them to sit, relax and enjoy each other’s company. Later on in this trip we had dinner with a group of 10 at Boma and the buffet-style meal didn’t work nearly as well. It seemed like there were always people missing from our table because they were at the buffet. This is especially true when you have small children.
However, though Liberty Tree Tavern remains my favorite table service restaurant at Magic Kingdom, it will likely be a few years now before we return. I really want to give the other 6 restaurants another try first. But I could change my mind…especially if we are there with a large group again.