Our First Ever Visit to The Beak and Barrel – May 2026

The Beak and Barrel opened in August 2025, which was several months after our last Disney World trip. So this was our first opportunity to check out this Pirates of the Caribbean-themed bar located in Magic Kingdom’s Adventureland, near the Pirates of the Caribbean ride exit. I made two reservations for The Beak and Barrel during our 10 night trip. The first of these was on our 4th night, so the three of us could check it out before the rest of group (which included our two young grandchildren) joined us. I made a second reservation for the 7 of us later in the week, but planned to cancel it if we didn’t think the kids would enjoy it.

So our first reservation was at 10:25 p.m. on a Saturday night. Not an ideal time, but it was all that was available. I knew going in to this that there would be a chance we would be seated with other guests so I wasn’t too surprised when the three of us were seated at a table with five ladies. That was fine, as they were very nice. However, what wasn’t fine is that we were seated in a back room and not in the main room of the bar where all of the action was taking place. So we completely missed out on the fun atmosphere, which is the primary reason that we went there.

But we tried to make the best of it anyway and ordered some drinks and a snack to share. Unfortunately Andrew wasn’t carrying his driver’s license with him to prove his age (he’s 30) so they wouldn’t serve him an alcoholic beverage. Thought he had a digital copy in his Apple wallet on his phone, they would not accept it. I tried to get him to order a non-alcoholic beverage but he passed.

I did though order one of their Non-Alcoholic Specialty Beverages and Don went for a Signature Cocktail. Here were the options…

My drink is pictured on the left and was the South Seas Splash (a Tropical infusion of Sprite, Pineapple, Mango and Guava Juices) for $7.00. Don’s was the Salty Seas mARRRgarita (Lalo Blanco Tequila, Cointreau Liqueur, Ube, and Lime) for $20.00.

My drink was small and most of it was ice. It was basically watered down (from all the ice) carbonated fruit juice. Definitely not worth $7.00 so I gave it a rating of only 2. Don’s was also small and heavy on the ice. While it tasted fine, it was way overpriced. He also gave his drink a 2.

So was the food better than the drinks?

As you can see, the food offerings here are pretty limited, basically only three things if you don’t count the two versions of corn cakes as different options. There was really only one thing that was of interest to me.

We chose the…

Cook’s Corn Griddle Cakes with Chipotle-braised Chicken – Warm Corn Cakes stuffed with Melted Cheese, Lime Sour Cream, Chili Peppers, and topped with Cotija Cheese – $14.00

The corn cakes (aka arepas) were good but nothing about them stood out as being especially good. I would probably give them an average rating of 3. I will admit though that had we been eating the arepas while enjoying the entertainment in the other room, this probably would have received a higher rating.

As we were leaving we stopped for a minute or two to look around the main area of the bar, where all of the fun was happening…

As you probably can tell, I’m still a bit salty about being stuck in the back room where it was pretty boring. During our walk back to the Contemporary that night, I got on the Disney app and canceled our second reservation later that week for our soon to be group of 7.

This is likely a one and done for me. Thought I’m glad I tried it, in my opinion, Trader Sam’s at the Polynesian offers a similar but better experience.